Dave's Corner of the Universe

Where strange fact and stranger fiction collide

He Stole Enstines Brain! Redux

Sometimes life takes a twist that you just need to deal with, and hobbies need to take a back seat. I am at that point now. Finding that I have other things I need to focus on, I am forced to limit my writing for a time. But still I don’t want to ignore my blog, so I am going to repost a blog that I did way back in June 13th 2013. This was one of my first posts.

Most of the people who fallow DCotU now came to in 2014, so I don’t feel too much like a cheater, and well sometimes a story is so good it needs to be told twice.

Albert Einstein is regarded by many as the smartest man who ever lived. His name is synonymous with intelligence. He is the Mick Jagger of mathematicians. But what happened to his brain after his death is an odyssey in to the absurd.

Einstein died of natural causes on April 17th 1955 in the Princeton Hospital.(1) The pathologist on duty, when that momentous event occurred was named Thomas Harvey. It is generally accepted that Einstein and his family had requested that his brain with the rest of his body be cremated. Dr. Harvey however couldn’t bring himself to allow something that could possibly unlock the nature of genius be destroyed so he walked out with the famous scientist’s brain (and apparently his eyeballs, which for some bazaar reason he gave to Einstein’s eye doctor.) inside his lunch box. (2)

Once the theft was discovered it understandably created a public outcry. Harvey refused to give up his souvenir, and a potential legal show down was averted when Hans Einstein, Albert’s son consented to allow Harvey to do further research on the brain. The problem was that Harvey was a Pathologist not a neuroscientist. He didn’t really have access to the type of equipment that was required to perform a through and scientific study the great man’s brain. And he defiantly didn’t have the proper tools lying around on his kitchen table where most of his research was being conducted.

Also any dead meat be it the brain of a scientist or a pound of old hamburger begins to rot after a while. So Harvey calls up a friend for some embalming hints and attempts to preserve the brain by injecting a 11.4% formalin solution through the internal carotid arteries and  then after that suspended the intact brain in 10% formalin fluid. Harvey then   photographed the brain from many angles. We can’t be sure what his motivations were for documenting the event if it was to be through in his scientific study or if it was for his own future self-aggrandizement. He then dissected it into about 240 blocks (each about 1 cm3) and encased the segments in a plastic-like material called collodion.

The fact that Albert’s family gave retroactive consent to Harvey’s filching of  Einstein’s brain, temporarily created a truce between him and his employers.  But eventually he was fired from his job because he didn’t make good on his promise to publish a paper on Einstein’s Brain. (4)

After his divorce Harvey would become a drifter and go through a series of medical job’s and relationships/marriages. Apparently claiming to have Einstein’s brain in a mason jar on your cupboard’s shelf is a great pick up line, but actually having Einstein’s brain in a mason jar on your cupboard’s shelf plays havoc on your domestic life. Finally he would lose his medical license and be forced to take a job at a plastic factory. (5)

In 1997 Harvey and freelanced journalist  Michael Paterniti, took off on a cross country road trip to meet Ernestine’s granddaughter, with Einstein’s brain in the trunk of Paterniti’s Buick Skylark. Harvey was thinking about giving the woman her grandfather’s brain, but well she wasn’t really all that crazy about the idea, so in the end Harvey returned to the scene of the crime all those years ago, the pathology lab in Princeton Hospital  and returned the dissected brain to the new M.E. who held his old job. (6)

In 1994 when the whereabouts of Einstein’s brains were still in question, documentary film maker Kevin Hull made a movie chronicling Dr. Kenji Sugamoto’s attempt to discover the wear about of the man who taught him about “…Science and love…” (7)

The movie is so over top that Swiss academic deemed Michael Hagner deemed it a hoax (8) Understandably so, Dr. Sugamoto with his unkempt hair, looks like a combination of Heroes’  Hiro Nakamura and History Channel’s Ancient Aliens  talking head Giorgio Tsoukalo. He rhythmically shifts his weight from his  left to right leg as if in a hypnotized awe as he stares at Einstein’s portrait in stain glass at the National Cathedral, and his  almost zombie-like obsession when he goes up to total strangers declares in pidgin English “…I want to see Einstein’s brain… I want to see Einstein’s brain…” seemingly transform the man in to a caricature.

When Michael Hagner was assured by colleges that Sugamoto was actually a real person, he was force to proclaim Nichts ist absurder als die Realität or Truth is in fact stranger than fiction. (9)

1)      http://dailyprincetonian.com/2006/10/05/16076/

2)      Dark Matter: 2011 The Science Channel

3)      http://lifescience.bioquant.com/gallery/the-exceptional-brain-of-albert-einstein

4)      Relics: Einstein Brains. (Ken Hall 1994) Season 1 Episode 2

5)      Dark Matter 2011 The Science Channel

6)      http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=4602913

7)      Relics Einstein Brains. (Ken Hull 1994), Season 1, Episode 2

8)      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relics:_Einstein%27s_Brain#The_question_of_veracity

9)      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relics:_Einstein%27s_Brain#The_question_of_veracity

3 comments on “He Stole Enstines Brain! Redux

  1. Mike
    November 24, 2014

    The notion that one could determine how Einstein came up with his theories by examining his pilfered brain is like hoping to discover the secret of Sandy Koufax’ pitching by dissecting his severed arm.

    • davekheath
      November 24, 2014

      True. I think in ways Einstein’s brain became more symbolic than anything else.

  2. Pingback: News that Stays News | M.C. Tuggle, Writer

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on November 23, 2014 by in Uncategorized and tagged , , .
%d bloggers like this: